Peoria’s pizza scene is a quintessential Midwest blend of old-school icons, neighborhood haunts, and inspired new favorites.
Whether you crave cracker-thin tavern-cut slices, hearty deep dish, or gourmet pies with creative toppings, Peoria delivers for every kind of pizza lover.
Here are the five best pizza spots in Peoria for 2025—each celebrated for their flavor, value, and loyal local following.
1. Agatucci’s Restaurant
Operating since 1926, Agatucci’s is Peoria’s pizza institution.
Their signature thin, crispy crust, sweet tomato sauce, and edge-to-edge toppings have achieved legendary status.
The orange-colored Agatucci’s House Salad and the distinctive, Italian sausage-laden pies keep generations of locals coming back.
Order the famous Tiger Pie and a pitcher of beer for the true Peoria experience.
2. Tyroni’s Italian Café
Tyroni’s serves up some of the best tavern-style, thin-crust pizza in town.
Known for its buttery crust, spicy-sweet red sauce, and friendly, bustling vibe, this is the spot for a classic Peoria pie—tiny squares, plenty of cheese, and generous toppings.
The “Super Tyroni” with sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms is a crowd favorite. Dine in for the local camaraderie or grab a takeout for pizza night.
3. Hoops Pub & Pizza
A downtown staple since 1985, Hoops is as much about the lively atmosphere as the pizza itself.
Their pies feature a secret house sauce and are loaded up Chicago-style, with lots of cheese and toppings.
From the classic sausage to their famous “Butcher Block” meat lover’s or inventive “Chicken Alfredo” pizza, Hoops is a must for lunch with friends, a game night, or downtown exploring.
4. Bruno’s Pizza
Known for both hand-tossed and thin-crust options, Bruno’s specializes in hearty, cheesy, old-school pies with a robust Italian red sauce.
The Supreme and Veggie pizzas are always winners, and regulars praise the friendly service and homey, no-frills setting.
A Peoria favorite for family dinners, delivery, and celebrating with a crowd.
5. Double A’s Pizza Sports Bar & Grill
A local go-to for sports fans and pizza lovers alike, Double A’s features classic and specialty pizzas with crispy, airy crusts and flavorful sauces.
Their lineup of craft beers and big screens elevate any game day, and creative options like the Buffalo Chicken and Taco Pizza keep the menu exciting.
Perfect for larger groups and anyone seeking a lively atmosphere and top-notch pie.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
