Durham’s pizza culture is every bit as innovative and energetic as the Bull City itself.
Combining Italian tradition, New York roots, Southern charm, and chef-driven creativity, Durham’s pizzerias deliver a fantastic array of top-tier pies.
Whether you’re after a classic slice, Neapolitan wood-fired flavors, or inventive Southern toppings, these five spots lead the way for pizza excellence in Durham in 2025.
1. Pizzeria Toro
Widely regarded as Durham’s pizza gold standard, Pizzeria Toro wows diners with its wood-fired, Neapolitan-inspired pies.
Expect a perfectly blistered crust, tangy San Marzano sauce, and a menu of creative, chef-driven toppings like soft egg and prosciutto or spicy greens and Italian sausage.
Its airy, urban setting in the heart of downtown and stellar bar program make it a foodie favorite for both locals and visitors.
2. Lilly’s Pizza
An institution with a cult following, Lilly’s Pizza—now a staple in Durham—serves up hand-tossed, crispy-chewy crusts and a wild variety of inventive topping combinations (try the “Cowtipper” or “Greek Goddess”).
With creative vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, plus an artsy, eclectic vibe, Lilly’s is a go-to for all kinds of pizza fans—from college students to families.
3. Pie Pushers
What started as one of Durham’s foodie-favorite food trucks has become a brick-and-mortar sensation.
Pie Pushers delivers thin, foldable NY-style pies and slices with high-quality cheese, spicy sauce, and fun specialty options (the “Green Monster” with pesto, or the “Jalapeño Popper”).
Their rooftop dining and central location make it perfect for a casual meal or a quick lunch downtown.
4. Cugino Forno
A regional star, Cugino Forno brings classic Italian craftsmanship to Durham with Neapolitan-style pizzas baked at 900°F.
Light, airy crusts, imported Italian ingredients, and no-nonsense toppings (margherita, salame, diavola, etc.) keep the focus on flavor and simplicity.
The light-filled, bustling space near the Durham Bulls ballpark makes it great for both date night and group dining.
5. Enzo’s Pizza Co.
A friendly, family-owned favorite close to Duke University, Enzo’s earns praise for its New York–style pies: big, foldable slices, classic toppings, and just the right sauce-to-cheese ratio.
The “Enzo’s Special” is a hit with students and locals alike, and their calzones, stombolis, and late-night hours make it a true Durham staple for any pizza craving.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
