San Mateo’s pizza scene thrives at the intersection of Silicon Valley’s cosmopolitan palate and deep-rooted Italian-American tradition.
These are San Mateo’s top five pies for 2025:
1. Amici’s East Coast Pizzeria
A Bay Area favorite, Amici’s brings thin, crisp, East Coast–style pies fired in a brick oven.
The “Boston” (anchovy, garlic, olives), “Buffalo Chicken,” and gluten-free options win raves, and their lively atmosphere and late hours attract a diverse local crowd.
2. Tomatina
Known for its hand-stretched dough, Tomatina delivers artisan pizzas—try their “Prosciutto & Arugula” or “Signature Margherita.”
Complement the pie with fresh salads or Italian pastas, all in a relaxed, modern setting.
Great for family outings and date night.
3. Windy City Pizza & BBQ
San Mateo’s most famous destination for true Chicago deep-dish—golden crust, chunky tomato sauce, and mountains of cheese.
The “Windy City Combo” (sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions) is iconic, but their BBQ menu keeps meat-lovers happy too.
Hearty, indulgent, and always satisfying.
4. Blue Line Pizza
Blue Line dishes out the best of both worlds—thick cornmeal-crust deep dish and crispy thin-crust creations.
Try the “Blue Line” (spinach, ricotta, mushrooms, Parmesan) or “Picasso” (sausage, roasted peppers).
They cater to vegan and gluten-free diners as well.
5. Mountain Mike’s Pizza
A West Coast chain that’s a party favorite, Mountain Mike’s offers signature crispy-edged pies, “curly pepperoni,” and a loaded “Mt. Veggiemore.”
Excellent for big groups, teams, or events, with salad bar and wings as crowd-pleasers.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
