5 Best Pizza Places in Sandy Springs, Georgia to Try

Sandy Springs, just north of Atlanta, offers a dynamic pizza scene with New York transplants, Southern twists, and gourmet hotspots.

Here are Sandy Springs’ best pizza joints in 2025.

1. Hearth Pizza Tavern

A perennial favorite, Hearth draws locals with wood-fired artisan pies and eclectic toppings—lamb sausage, local veggies, and creative sauces.

The “Georgia Peach” (prosciutto, fresh peaches, balsamic) and the “Hearth Pie” (Italian sausage, caramelized onions) are menu standouts.

Enjoy a craft cocktail or local brew on their lively patio.

2. Blue Moon Pizza

Known for its signature flattened, stone-baked crust and loads of cheese, Blue Moon offers up everything from classic pepperoni to BBQ chicken.

Their “Moon Pie” (pesto, sun-dried tomato, feta) is a house special.

Fun drinks, upbeat vibe, and excellent service make this a Sandy Springs institution.

3. Antico Pizza Napoletana

The Sandy Springs outpost of this Atlanta legend serves blazing-hot Neapolitan pies with pillowy crusts and imported Italian ingredients: San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte, and soppressata.

Try the “Margherita D.O.P.” or “Diavola.” Order at the counter, and enjoy the bustling, casual setting.

4. Clay’s Sports Café

Beloved for wings and pizza since the 1990s, Clay’s makes classic hand-tossed pies with a gooey, bubbly crust.

Try the meat-packed “Super Deluxe” or a Hawaiian pie alongside their signature ranch dressing. Laid-back, cash-only, and full of neighborhood charm.

5. Mellow Mushroom

A Southern chain that fits right in, Mellow Mushroom in Sandy Springs brings funky décor, craft beer, gluten-free/vegan options, and pies like the “Kosmic Karma” or “Mighty Meaty.”

The outdoor patio and energetic staff seal the deal for all ages.