Carmel, Indiana combines affluence, family-friendly suburban charm, and a sophisticated dining scene just north of Indianapolis.
These five pizzerias represent the best that Carmel offers in 2025, each contributing to this consistently top-ranked community.
1. Bazbeaux Pizza
A Central Indiana institution since 1986, Bazbeaux’s Carmel location serves creative, eclectic pizza in the heart of the Arts & Design District.
Their thin, crisp crust supports innovative combinations that pioneered elevated pizza in the Indianapolis area.
The pesto-based “Basilpesto” remains their signature creation, while options like the “Girish Delight” with eggplant and goat cheese showcase their sophisticated approach.
Early adoption of extensive vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options reflected forward-thinking menu planning.
The contemporary space with local artwork and spacious patio attracts diverse customers from families after Monon Trail outings to pre-concert diners headed to the Palladium.
2. Greek’s Pizzeria
This beloved local chain has perfected thin-crust, square-cut “Midwest style” pizza since 1969.
The Carmel location maintains the warm, brick-walled atmosphere and consistent quality that has generated multi-generational loyalty.
Their slightly sweet sauce, edge-to-edge toppings, and distinctive cheese blend create unmistakable flavor, while house-made breadsticks with garlic butter have achieved legendary status.
The “Greek’s Special” loaded with premium toppings represents their classic approach, while newer options cater to evolving tastes.
Located near Carmel High School, Greek’s has become a tradition for student celebrations, team gatherings, and family dinners.
3. Prodigy Burger & Bar
While primarily known for craft burgers, Prodigy has developed a devoted following for their distinctive “Midwest tavern-style” pizzas—thin, crispy crust cut into squares with slightly caramelized cheese extending to the edges.
Located in Carmel’s City Center development, their upscale sports-bar atmosphere appeals to both families and young professionals.
The “Carmel Carnivore” features house-smoked meats from their burger program, while the “Clay Terrace” combines prosciutto with fig jam and arugula for more sophisticated palates.
Their extensive craft beer selection, featuring many Indiana breweries, complements the pizza perfectly.
4. Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub
Founded by acclaimed Indianapolis chef Neal Brown, Pizzology brings artisanal Neapolitan-inspired pizza to Carmel’s discerning diners.
Their wood-fired oven produces beautifully blistered crusts with perfect chew, while toppings emphasize local sourcing and housemade components including hand-pulled mozzarella and house-cured meats.
The “Carmel Renaissance” features seasonal produce from nearby farms, while the “Meridian” combines wild mushrooms with truffle honey for sophisticated flavor.
The industrial-chic interior creates a modern yet comfortable atmosphere, while their craft cocktail program and thoughtful wine list elevate the dining experience beyond typical pizzerias.
Pizzology’s chef-driven approach and commitment to quality ingredients appeal particularly to Carmel’s well-traveled residents seeking authentic experiences.
5. Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub
This reinvented version of an Indiana pizza chain has successfully evolved from its 1970s origins into a modern craft pizza concept.
Their distinctive “Sicilian” deep-dish style features a light, airy crust despite its substantial height, while traditional thin-crust options satisfy diverse preferences.
The pizza is partially baked in view of customers before finishing to order, creating both entertainment and quality control.
The family-friendly atmosphere includes a self-serve beer wall featuring local craft options for adults and a dedicated kids’ area with activities.
Located near popular shopping destinations, Noble Roman’s provides a comfortable gathering place that balances nostalgia for longtime Indiana residents with contemporary expectations.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
