Brandon, Florida combines Tampa Bay proximity with its own distinct community character.
The pizza scene reflects this blend of Florida casual, family-friendly options, and creative newcomers. Here are Brandon’s five best pizzerias for 2025.
1. Cuzzins New York Pizza
Bringing authentic New York slices to West Florida, Cuzzins has perfected thin, foldable pizza with the ideal balance of chew and crispness.
Founded by actual cousins from Brooklyn, their commitment to authenticity includes importing water with mineral content similar to NYC’s to create the perfect dough.
The classic cheese slice showcases their exceptional foundation, while specialty pies like the “Brandon Heights” (named after a local neighborhood) incorporate Florida flavors.
The casual, family-friendly atmosphere features New York memorabilia alongside Tampa Bay sports décor, creating a welcoming environment for transplanted Northeasterners and locals alike.
2. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
Known for distinctive “well-done” pizza from 900-degree coal ovens, Anthony’s creates uniquely charred, crisp crusts that maintain a chewy interior.
Their simple, high-quality toppings like Italian imports and fresh mozzarella shine on this exceptional base.
The “Paul & Young Ron” with meatballs and ricotta has developed a regional following, while roasted cauliflower pizza demonstrates creative veggie applications.
3. Marco’s Pizza
While technically a chain, Marco’s Brandon location has distinguished itself through exceptional execution, community involvement, and personalized service.
Their dough made fresh daily, signature three-cheese blend, and house-made sauce create distinctively flavorful pies that consistently outperform other chain options.
The “White Cheezy” and “Pepperoni Magnifico” highlight their commitment to generous toppings and proper preparation.
Affordable family meal deals and efficient delivery make Marco’s a practical option for busy households, while their support of local schools through fundraisers has built genuine community connections.
4. Revolution Pizza Bar
Bringing craft beer culture and artisanal pizza together, Revolution offers hand-tossed, medium-thin crust pies in a modern, social atmosphere.
Their dough undergoes 48-hour fermentation for enhanced flavor, while creative toppings and combinations appeal to adventurous eaters.
The “Tampa Bay Cuban” reimagines the iconic sandwich as a pizza with mojo pork and mustard sauce, while the “Strawberry Fields” with local berries and balsamic glaze showcases Florida’s produce.
5. Precinct Pizza
Founded by a former New York City police officer, this law enforcement-themed pizzeria delivers authentic NY-style pies with generous dimensions and perfect texture.
The walls feature police memorabilia and badges from departments nationwide, creating a distinctive environment that honors first responders.
Their “9-1-1” pie loaded with meats and vegetables lives up to its emergency-inspired name, while traditional options satisfy pizza purists.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
