Paterson, New Jersey’s rich industrial history and diverse communities create a vibrant pizza scene in this North Jersey city.
From old-school Italian joints to innovative multicultural spots, these five pizzerias represent Paterson’s best in 2025.
1. Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant
A Paterson institution since 1931, Patsy’s represents authentic North Jersey pizza tradition with thin, crispy bar pies served in a classic tavern setting.
Their signature style features a cracker-thin crust that maintains perfect structural integrity beneath generous toppings.
The “Patsy’s Special” with sausage, onions, and peppers has remained unchanged for decades, while their square pan pizza offers a thicker alternative.
The historic bar room with original fixtures and photographs of old Paterson creates an authentic experience increasingly rare in contemporary restaurants.
2. Peruvian Pizza Palace
Exemplifying Paterson’s multicultural character, this innovative spot combines traditional pizza techniques with Peruvian flavors and ingredients.
Their hand-tossed pies feature conventional options alongside creative combinations like the “Lomo Saltado Pizza” inspired by Peru’s famous stir-fry, and “Aji Amarillo Chicken” with Peru’s distinctive yellow pepper sauce.
The vibrant, family-friendly space celebrates both Italian and Peruvian cultures through décor and music.
3. Mario’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
Representing classic Italian-American tradition, Mario’s delivers hand-tossed, New York-style pies with the perfect balance of chew and crispness.
The “Market Street Special” combines pepperoni, sausage, and vegetables on their excellent foundation, while their Sicilian-style thick square pizza has earned particular acclaim.
4. Silk City Pizza
Named after Paterson’s historic nickname, Silk City Pizza brings artisanal approach and local sourcing to this industrial city.
Their naturally leavened sourdough crust develops complex flavor through long fermentation, while seasonal ingredients create distinctive combinations.
The “Great Falls” with hot honey, sopressata, and fresh ricotta honors local landmarks, while rotating specials feature produce from nearby New Jersey farms.
5. Taskin Bakery & Pizza
This Turkish-owned establishment successfully combines Mediterranean flavors with traditional pizza, creating unique offerings that reflect Paterson’s Middle Eastern community.
Their distinctive pide (Turkish flatbread) pizzas feature boat-shaped crusts and toppings like soujouk sausage and kasseri cheese, while conventional round pizzas satisfy traditional preferences.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
