McAllen, Texas combines border culture, Rio Grande Valley traditions, and Tex-Mex innovation in this vibrant South Texas city.
From authentic Italian to creative border fusion, these five pizzerias represent McAllen’s best in 2025.
1. Il Forno a Legna
Bringing authentic Italian techniques to the border, Il Forno a Legna centers around a wood-burning oven imported from Naples.
Their Neapolitan-style pizzas feature light, airy crusts with perfect char spots and high-quality toppings.
The classic Margherita showcases their excellent execution of fundamentals, while the “Rio Grande” with chorizo and roasted poblanos introduces South Texas flavors.
2. La Pizza de Emiliano’s
This family-owned establishment perfectly represents McAllen’s bicultural character by blending traditional pizza with Mexican and Tex-Mex flavors.
Their medium-thick crust provides an ideal foundation for innovative combinations like the “Enchilada Pizza” with red chile sauce and the “Fajita Supreme” with grilled beef and peppers.
3. Fancy Slice Pizza Company
Representing McAllen’s growing craft food scene, Fancy Slice offers New York-inspired artisanal pizza with creative Texas twists.
Their thin, foldable crust maintains perfect texture through a 48-hour fermentation process, while premium ingredients create distinctive flavor profiles.
The “Valley Heat” with locally grown peppers and honey showcases regional produce, while traditional options satisfy pizza purists.
4. Nino’s Pizza & Restaurant
A McAllen tradition for decades, Nino’s delivers classic Italian-American comfort in a family-friendly setting.
Their hand-tossed pies feature a medium crust with slightly sweet sauce and generous cheese and toppings.
The “Nino’s Special” with multiple meats and vegetables has remained unchanged for generations, while newer menu items accommodate evolving tastes.
5. Fiesta Pizza Buffet
Uniquely reflecting South Texas culture, Fiesta Pizza combines an all-you-can-eat format with distinctive border flavors.
Their medium-crust pizzas include both traditional options and creative combinations like barbacoa, cilantro-lime chicken, and Mexican street corn-inspired toppings.
The bright, family-friendly atmosphere and affordable pricing make this especially popular for large gatherings and celebrations.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
