Hialeah combines Cuban influence, working-class roots, and vibrant community spirit in this distinctive Miami-Dade city.
These five pizzerias represent Hialeah’s best in 2025, each offering a unique slice of local flavor.
1. Mama Jennie’s Italian Restaurant
A Hialeah institution for over 40 years, Mama Jennie’s delivers classic Italian-American pizza with a medium-thick crust and generous toppings.
The “Hialeah Special” combines pepperoni, sausage, and green peppers on their time-tested recipe, while their Sicilian square pizza has sustained generations of local families.
The warm, nostalgic atmosphere with family photos and vintage decor creates an authentic experience that welcomes multi-generational dining.
2. La Pizza Cubana
Uniquely reflecting Hialeah’s dominant Cuban culture, this innovative spot combines traditional pizza techniques with Cuban flavors and ingredients.
Their hand-tossed crust provides the foundation for creative combinations like the “Cubano Pizza” with mojo pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard sauce inspired by the famous sandwich, and the “Ropa Vieja” featuring Cuba’s classic shredded beef dish.
3. Tony’s Pizza
This neighborhood favorite delivers reliable New York-style pies with thin, foldable crusts and the perfect balance of sauce and cheese.
Available both by the slice and as whole pies, their pizza offers consistent quality at reasonable prices.
The casual, family-friendly setting makes Tony’s a go-to for quick lunches and weeknight dinners.
Beyond pizza, their complete menu of Italian classics and Cuban-influenced sides reflects Hialeah’s multicultural character.
4. Flamingo Pizza & Restaurant
Named after Hialeah’s iconic Flamingo Plaza, this family-owned establishment serves excellent thin-crust pies with generous toppings and a distinctly local vibe.
The “Westland Special” (named for the popular mall) features a combination of traditional toppings on their well-executed base, while the “Okeechobee” with chorizo and sweet plantains incorporates Caribbean flavors.
5. Palm Avenue Pizza
Located on one of Hialeah’s main thoroughfares, this modern pizzeria brings artisanal techniques to a traditionally working-class community.
Their hand-crafted dough undergoes 48-hour fermentation for enhanced flavor, while creative topping combinations appeal to evolving tastes.
The “El Teque” with queso blanco and guava pays homage to a favorite Cuban pastry in pizza form, while traditional options satisfy pizza purists.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
