Yonkers combines New York City proximity, diverse neighborhoods, and rich Italian-American heritage in Westchester County’s largest city.
These five pizzerias represent Yonkers’ best in 2025, each delivering authentic New York pizza excellence.
1. Mulino’s Trattoria
A Yonkers institution for over 50 years, Mulino’s embodies classic New York Italian-American pizza tradition with thin, foldable crust, bright tomato sauce, and quality mozzarella.
Their coal-fired oven produces distinctive charred spots and perfect texture that generations of locals consider the gold standard.
The “Mulino’s Special” combines traditional toppings on this exceptional foundation, while their white pizza with ricotta has developed a devoted following.
2. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
This legendary New Haven institution’s Yonkers location brings Connecticut’s distinctive coal-fired style to Westchester.
Their thin, oblong pies with slightly charred, chewy crust have attracted pizza enthusiasts from throughout the region.
The iconic “White Clam” pizza with fresh clams, garlic, and olive oil (no cheese) demonstrates their commitment to tradition, while the “Original Tomato Pie” showcases the perfect simplicity of their approach.
3. Palisade Pizza
Serving Northwest Yonkers for decades, Palisade Pizza delivers quintessential neighborhood slice-shop excellence with thin, properly foldable New York pies and consistently excellent execution.
Available both by the slice and as whole pies, their pizza represents the everyday New York pizza experience at its best.
The casual, counter-service setup makes this a local favorite for quick lunches and convenient takeout.
Beyond pizza, their complete Italian-American menu satisfies diverse cravings.
4. Fortina
This modern, chef-driven concept brings wood-fired innovation to Yonkers’ evolving restaurant scene.
Their distinctive oven produces light, airy crusts with perfect chewiness, while creative topping combinations appeal to contemporary tastes.
The “Westchester” with honey, hot Italian sausage, and broccoli rabe has become a signature creation, while their “Rita” Margherita demonstrates their ability to perfect classics.
5. Raceway Pizza
Named for the historic Yonkers Raceway, this family-owned establishment delivers consistent quality with medium-thin crust and generous toppings.
The “Trifecta” with three meats plays on racing terminology while delivering hearty satisfaction, while the “Empire City” (named for the adjacent casino) features a creative combination of flavors.
Their efficient delivery service covers most Yonkers neighborhoods, making Raceway a reliable option for home dining.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
