Surprise combines rapid growth, retirement communities, and Arizona desert lifestyle in this expanding Phoenix suburb.
These five pizzerias represent Surprise’s best in 2025, each bringing distinctive flavor to this diverse community.
1. Bottega Pizzeria Ristorante
This family-owned gem brings authentic Neapolitan techniques to Surprise with a wood-burning oven imported from Italy.
Their light, airy crusts with perfect leopard spotting provide the foundation for both traditional combinations and Southwestern-inspired creations.
The classic Margherita showcases their commitment to quality fundamentals, while the “Sonoran” with green chiles and chorizo incorporates regional flavors.
2. Rosati’s Pizza
This Chicago-based chain’s Surprise location has distinguished itself through exceptional execution and community involvement.
Their deep-dish pies with buttery crust, chunky tomato sauce, and generous cheese layers bring authentic Midwest flavor to the desert.
The thin-crust “tavern style” cut in squares offers a lighter alternative equally rooted in Chicago tradition.
3. State 48 Brewery & Pizza
Combining craft beer culture with creative pizza, State 48 offers wood-fired pies in a lively atmosphere that showcases Arizona pride.
Their thin, crispy crust develops complex flavor through extended fermentation, while innovative toppings celebrate local ingredients.
The “Grand Avenue” features Arizona-grown dates and locally-produced cheese, while the “Sun City Special” with roasted vegetables appeals to health-conscious retirees.
4. Bell Road Pizza
This quintessential neighborhood pizzeria delivers consistent New York-style pies with thin, foldable crusts and generous toppings at family-friendly prices.
The “Surprise Supreme” combines traditional ingredients on their well-executed foundation, while the “Spring Training Special” (available during baseball season) celebrates the city’s Cactus League connection.
The casual, welcoming atmosphere makes Bell Road popular for team gatherings and family dinners alike.
5. Oregano’s Pizza Bistro
This Arizona favorite’s Surprise location brings their signature Chicago-meets-California style to the Northwest Valley.
Their thin-crust “Chicago style” pizza cut in squares and deep-dish “stuffed” pies satisfy diverse preferences with consistent quality.
The nostalgic 1950s décor, friendly service, and famous pizza cookie dessert create a complete dining experience that appeals across generations.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
