Hayward combines Bay Area diversity, working-class roots, and evolving urban renewal in this distinctive East Bay city.
These five pizzerias represent Hayward’s best in 2025, each bringing unique flavor to the local community.
1. Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace
A Hayward institution since 1979, Bronco Billy’s delivers old-school California pizza with medium-thick crust and generous toppings in a distinctive Wild West setting.
Their “Hayward Special” combines multiple meats and vegetables on their time-tested recipe, while their sourdough crust option offers authentic San Francisco flavor.
The family-friendly atmosphere with Western memorabilia and arcade games creates a complete entertainment experience beyond just dining.
2. Acqua e Farina
Bringing authentic Neapolitan techniques to downtown Hayward, Acqua e Farina creates artisanal pies with perfect leopard-spotted crusts from their imported wood-burning oven.
Their commitment to traditional methods includes house-made mozzarella, imported Italian flour, and adherence to strict Neapolitan standards.
The classic Margherita showcases their excellent execution, while the “East Bay” with locally-sourced seasonal ingredients connects Italian tradition to California’s agricultural bounty.
3. Pizza Guys
This regional chain’s Hayward location has distinguished itself through consistent quality, community involvement, and adaptation to local preferences.
Their hand-tossed pies feature a medium crust with slightly sweet sauce and generous toppings.
The “Mission Boulevard Special” honors Hayward’s main thoroughfare with a crowd-pleasing combination, while their specialty pizzas incorporate flavors reflecting the area’s diverse population.
Efficient delivery service and family meal deals make Pizza Guys a reliable option for busy households.
4. Ghazni Afghan Kabobs & Pizza
Uniquely reflecting Hayward’s significant Afghan community, Ghazni successfully combines traditional Afghan cuisine with quality pizza in a distinctive fusion approach.
Their hand-tossed pies include both conventional options and creative combinations like the “Kabob Pizza” featuring seasoned meats from their Afghan menu and the “Bolani Pizza” inspired by Afghan stuffed flatbread.
The family-run operation maintains both culinary traditions with authenticity and skill, creating a dining experience that celebrates Hayward’s cultural diversity.
5. The Pizza Shop
This unassuming name belies exceptional quality at this neighborhood favorite delivering authentic New York-style slices with thin, foldable crusts and perfect texture.
Founded by East Coast transplants seeking to bring genuine NYC pizza to the Bay Area, their commitment to traditional techniques includes hand-tossed dough, deck ovens, and proper ingredients.
The casual, no-frills setting focuses on quality execution rather than atmosphere, making The Pizza Shop popular for takeout and quick meals.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
