New Haven is America’s most historic and influential pizza city, home to the distinctive “apizza” style that has defined Connecticut’s unique contribution to pizza culture.
These five legendary establishments represent New Haven’s unparalleled pizza heritage in 2025.
1. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
The undisputed godfather of New Haven pizza since 1925, Pepe’s defines the city’s distinctive style with oblong pies featuring thin, charred, chewy crust from coal-fired ovens.
Their iconic white clam pizza—fresh littlenecks, garlic, olive oil, oregano, and grated cheese—remains among America’s most celebrated specialty pies nearly a century after its creation.
The original Wooster Street location still draws lines of pizza pilgrims from across the country, while the no-frills atmosphere maintains authentic connection to New Haven’s working-class roots.
2. Sally’s Apizza
Founded by Pepe’s nephew Salvatore Consiglio in 1938, Sally’s maintains fierce independence and distinctive character in the New Haven pizza pantheon.
Their thin-crust pies from a coal-fired oven feature slightly different characteristics from their famous neighbor—often charred more aggressively with a distinctive chew and flavor profile.
The tomato pie with just sauce, garlic, and light cheese showcases their exceptional foundation, while loyal customers debate the subtle differences between Sally’s and Pepe’s with religious fervor.
3. Modern Apizza
Operating since 1934, Modern represents the third pillar of New Haven’s historic pizza trinity.
Their oil-fueled brick oven produces distinctive pies with less char than coal-fired competitors but exceptional flavor and texture.
The “Italian Bomb” loaded with bacon, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, pepper, and garlic has achieved legendary status among New Haven specialties.
The neighborhood location slightly removed from the Wooster Street epicenter creates a more local, less tourist-heavy atmosphere.
4. Bar
Representing New Haven pizza’s evolution for younger generations, Bar combines nightlife energy with excellent brick-oven pies in a renovated garment factory.
Their signature mashed potato pizza topped with bacon has created a new New Haven classic, while their house-brewed beer complements the menu perfectly.
The industrial-chic space transforms from family-friendly restaurant earlier in the evening to vibrant nightclub later, attracting Yale students and young professionals.
5. Zuppardi’s Apizza
Though technically in neighboring West Haven, Zuppardi’s earns its place among New Haven’s elite through exceptional quality since 1934 and distinctive contributions to the regional style.
Their fresh clam pie differs from Pepe’s by using shucked-to-order fresh clams rather than pre-shucked, creating a different flavor profile that many aficionados prefer.
The slightly thicker crust than typical New Haven style provides different textural experience while maintaining essential character.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
