5 Best Pizza Places in Kenosha, Wisconsin to Try

Kenosha combines Lake Michigan beauty, manufacturing heritage, and location between Milwaukee and Chicago influences.

Here’s where locals find their favorite pizza in 2025.

1. Tenuta’s Deli & Pizza

This legendary Kenosha institution does double duty as both the area’s most famous Italian deli and a source for incredible take-and-bake pizzas that generations of locals consider essential to family gatherings.

Their thick, slightly sweet crust loaded with quality ingredients from their own deli creates that nostalgic flavor that defines Kenosha pizza traditions.

The historic market setting hasn’t changed much in decades, and that’s exactly how Kenoshans like it.

2. Villa D’Carlo Pizzeria

This Kenosha institution since 1957 serves distinctive thin-crust pies cut in squares – the authentic tavern style that bridges Wisconsin and Chicago pizza traditions.

Their slightly sweet sauce and edge-to-edge toppings create that nostalgic flavor that’s fueled countless celebrations and family gatherings for decades.

The vintage setting with red vinyl booths creates authentic old-school vibes, while the owners still make dough using the original recipe that made them famous.

3. Rustic Road Brewing Company & Pizza

This downtown brewpub creates exceptional sourdough pizzas designed to pair perfectly with their house-brewed beers.

Their naturally leavened dough develops complex flavor through extended fermentation, while creative toppings often incorporate elements from their brewing process.

The “Kenosha Harbor” featuring ingredients that change seasonally celebrates local connections, while the renovated historic building contributes to downtown’s ongoing renaissance.

4. Valeo’s Pizza

This neighborhood favorite delivers consistent quality with that perfect balance of Wisconsin cheese, slightly sweet sauce, and a crust with just the right chew.

Their hand-tossed pies feature generous toppings at reasonable prices that keep local families coming back weekly.

Nothing fancy here – just reliable pizza that tastes like Kenosha has for generations.

5. The Buzz Café & Pizza

This unique concept successfully combines quality pizza with coffee shop culture in a vibrant space that attracts diverse customers throughout the day.

Their thin, crispy crust provides the perfect foundation for both traditional toppings and creative combinations that change regularly.

Beyond pizza, their excellent coffee program makes this a versatile location where people gather for everything from morning meetings to dinner.