High plains and ag heritage define Greeley, but the city’s youth, thanks to the university and an influx of newcomers, sets the pace for a pleasantly surprising food scene—old-fashioned, friendly, and plugged into international taste.
Santeramo’s Pizza House & Italian Food
Greeley’s Italian comfort-food legend, Santeramo’s has been a family favorite since the 1960s.
Heaping plates of spaghetti, lasagna with bubbly cheese, chicken parmesan, and garlic knots waft fragrance through the cozy, old-school dining room.
The bar pours Colorado craft beers and the dessert case always boasts a decadent house tiramisu. It feels like Sunday supper—even on a Tuesday.
Lucky Fins Seafood Grill
Seafood in cattle country? Absolutely—Lucky Fins surprises with fresh-shucked oysters, wood-fired salmon, Baja fish tacos, and creative sushi.
The menu skews West Coast and pan-Asian, with poke bowls alongside fried shrimp platters.
The bar scene is lively and the family-friendly vibe is real: Greeley’s beach day, no matter the season.
Kenny’s Steakhouse
The city’s trusted spot for sizzling steaks, slow-roasted prime rib, and grilled pork chops, Kenny’s attracts celebrations, first dates, and multi-generational Sunday dinners.
The servers greet regulars like friends, the cocktail list is robust, and the double-baked potatoes are pure culinary nostalgia.
The walls lined with cattle photos and rodeo memorabilia remind you you’re in true beef country.
La Mariposa Restaurant & Margarita House
Beloved by Greeley’s large Latino community and a go-to for everyone who craves enchiladas, sizzling fajitas, and green chile-smothered burritos.
Margarita pitchers headline every celebration, and mariachi bands appear on weekends.
The murals, bright colors, and family-size platters create an always-festive vibe.
Earl’s Kitchen + Bar
With a polished but comfortable open space, Earl’s brings a big-city feel: creative burgers, craft cocktails, sushi, truffle fries, and hearty salads.
It’s a favorite for business lunches, students, and date-nighters alike, with a bustling bar and slick service. Their brunch is an event, featuring creative Benedicts and signature breakfast cocktails.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
