5 Best Local Favorite Restaurants in Jacksonville, Florida to Try

A river city with salt in its lungs, Jacksonville straddles marsh and metropolis, barbecue smoke and French technique, late-night taco runs and anniversary dinners.

Neighborhoods tell their own stories—San Marco’s polish, Five Points’ edge, the easy sprawl of the beaches.

Restaurant Orsay

In Avondale, Orsay blends Parisian bistro instincts with Southern comfort, and the results feel inevitable.

Steak frites whisper of the Left Bank; shrimp and grits speak with a coastal drawl; oysters arrive like tiny, briny celebrations.

The bar is a world of its own—proper martinis, thoughtful wines, and a hum that says you’ve chosen well.

Black Sheep

Five Points’ rooftop roost, Black Sheep marries skyline views with a menu that likes to color outside the lines.

Pimento cheese might sit beside Korean‑spiced short ribs; a crisp fried chicken sandwich could share space with seasonal veg that actually steals the spotlight.

Brunch is a minor civic event; sunset cocktails are a ritual.

Matthew’s

White tablecloths without the stiffness, Matthew’s in San Marco has long been the city’s fine‑dining compass.

Plates are layered and precise—luxurious sauces, pristine seafood, a steak that respects its lineage—yet the service keeps it human.

It’s where milestones go to be marked and where the kitchen shows just how far Jacksonville’s palate can stretch.

TacoLu

Down at the beach, TacoLu is a bright, happy chaos of tacos, tequila, and coastal breeze.

From Baja‑crisped fish to slow‑braised pork, the fillings are the point, but don’t sleep on queso that disappears too fast or a margarita that balances lime, salt, and sunshine.

Expect a wait; nobody minds. The vibe’s the appetizer.

Safe Harbor Seafood

Mayport shrimp aren’t just a commodity here—they’re a story, and Safe Harbor tells it with pride. Order simply: peel‑and‑eat shrimp, blackened local catch, hush puppies that earn their keep.

You can taste the short trip from boat to plate, and the view—docks, gulls, tide—does the rest.

Get the All-American Travel Secrets!

Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!

Leave this field blank

Leave a Comment