Appleton, Wisconsin, nestled along the scenic Fox River, is a city where Midwestern warmth meets a vibrant, evolving food scene.
From historic breweries to Mediterranean gems and inventive bistros, Appleton’s restaurants reflect the city’s rich cultural tapestry and its residents’ passion for great food.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, these five beloved establishments offer a delicious journey through the flavors and stories that make Appleton unique.
1. Apollon
Since 1994, Apollon has been Appleton’s go-to destination for authentic Mediterranean cuisine.
The restaurant’s elegant, art-filled interior sets the stage for a dining experience that feels both sophisticated and welcoming.
Signature dishes like lamb souvlaki, baked feta saganaki, shrimp with ouzo, and slow-cooked lemon chicken transport diners straight to the Greek isles.
The homemade baklava is a must for dessert, and the wine list features selections from Greece and beyond.
Apollon’s attentive staff and gracious service make every meal feel like a celebration.
Locals love the restaurant for its consistency, quality, and the sense of occasion it brings to both special events and casual dinners.
Whether you’re a fan of Mediterranean flavors or simply seeking a memorable meal, Apollon is a cherished Appleton staple.
2. Stone Arch Brewpub
Housed in a historic 1858 stone brewery, Stone Arch Brewpub is a testament to Appleton’s brewing heritage and love for hearty, comforting fare.
The menu pays homage to Wisconsin’s culinary traditions, featuring beer cheese soup, fried perch, cheese curds, bratwurst, and wood-fired pizzas.
House-brewed beers like Honey Wheat and Bavarian Dunkelweizen are local favorites, and the stone-walled beer cellar often hosts live music, adding to the lively, communal atmosphere.
Stone Arch’s rustic charm, commitment to local ingredients, and welcoming vibe make it a favorite for family gatherings, casual nights out, and anyone seeking a true taste of Wisconsin.
Locals praise the pub for its inventive takes on classic dishes and its role as a gathering place for the community.
3. Rye Restaurant
Located in the CopperLeaf Hotel, Rye Restaurant offers a modern, minimalist setting and a menu focused on locally sourced ingredients.
Dishes like seared duck breast with cherry gastrique, prime ribeye with Wisconsin mushrooms, and rotating seasonal soups showcase the kitchen’s creativity and commitment to quality.
The local cheese plate and craft cocktails are especially popular, making Rye a top choice for business dinners, romantic evenings, or special celebrations.
Patrons love Rye for its stylish ambiance, attentive service, and the way it elevates local flavors.
The restaurant’s dedication to supporting Wisconsin farmers and producers resonates with Appleton’s food-loving community.
4. Basil Café
Basil Café brings the vibrant flavors of Southeast Asia to Appleton, specializing in Thai and Lao cuisine.
The menu features dishes like khao poon noodle soup, sticky rice with grilled chicken, tangy papaya salad, and fiery green curry with eggplant and pork.
The cozy, cheerful space is filled with regulars who appreciate the owners’ willingness to explain spice levels and recommend off-menu items.
Locals flock to Basil Café for its authenticity, bold flavors, and the sense of adventure it brings to the Appleton dining scene.
Whether you’re a fan of Southeast Asian cuisine or looking to try something new, Basil Café is a must-visit for foodies in the Fox Valley.
5. Carmella’s: An Italian Bistro
Carmella’s is Appleton’s answer to classic Italian dining, offering an intimate setting, homemade pasta, and wood-fired pizzas.
The bistro emphasizes fresh, local ingredients and a carefully curated wine list, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for both casual meals and special occasions.
Diners rave about Carmella’s for its authentic flavors, attentive service, and the way it brings a little slice of Italy to Wisconsin.
Whether you’re celebrating with family or enjoying a quiet dinner for two, Carmella’s is a beloved spot that captures the heart of Appleton’s food scene.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
