5 Best New Restaurants in Pensacola, Florida that Locals Keep Coming Back For

Independence has always had deep history and small‑town charm, but its food scene has quietly been catching up.

Around the Square, along 39th Street, and in the busier commercial corridors, you’ll now find modern barbecue, updated comfort food, and globally inspired spots that feel much more “Kansas City metro” than sleepy suburb.

These five relatively new or newly buzz‑worthy restaurants are great places to start.


1. A Little BBQ Joint

A Little BBQ Joint feels exactly like the kind of place you want your local barbecue to be: casual, slightly quirky, and fully focused on smoke.

Inside it’s all Americana decor, neon, license plates, and a friendly, lived‑in vibe.

The menu hits the KC‑style highlights: thick‑cut burnt ends, pulled pork, brisket, ribs, and turkey, plus sandwiches stacked with whatever combo you’re craving.

Sides lean classic—beans, slaw, fries, cheesy potatoes, and cornbread—and portions are generous.

Best for:

  • Burnt ends and ribs
  • Casual dinners with a group
  • A no‑frills intro to local BBQ flavor

2. Vivilore

Tucked into the Englewood Arts District, Vivilore is part restaurant, part art gallery, part garden escape.

The setting is half the draw: a rambling historic building filled with antiques and artwork, plus a leafy patio that feels miles from the traffic on 40 Highway.

The menu leans upscale American bistro with some Midwestern comfort mixed in—think steaks, salmon, pork chops, creative chicken dishes, and well‑built salads and starters.

Plating is thoughtful without being too fussy, and it works well for date night, anniversaries, or a slightly dressier lunch.

Best for:

  • Romantic dinners or special occasions
  • Patio dining in nice weather
  • A more polished “night out” in Independence

3. Courthouse Exchange

Right off the historic Independence Square, Courthouse Exchange is a basement‑level pub with a loyal following and an updated neighborhood‑tavern feel.

Exposed brick, cozy booths, and a friendly bar make it easy to settle in for a long meal.

The food is classic American comfort—burgers, sandwiches, wraps, big salads, fried appetizers, and daily specials like meatloaf, chicken‑fried steak, or pot roast.

It’s not fancy, but it’s well‑executed, consistent, and feels very “local Independence.”

Best for:

  • Casual lunches on or near the Square
  • Burgers, fries, and a beer
  • Relaxed, family‑friendly dinners

4. Cafe Verona

Also on the Square, Cafe Verona brings a slightly more refined Italian vibe to downtown Independence.

The interior is warm and brick‑lined, with murals and soft lighting; in good weather, the patio is one of the nicer places in town to sit outside.

Expect a menu of Italian‑American favorites: pasta dishes (alfredo, bolognese, carbonara, seafood pastas), chicken and veal specialties, risotto, and pizzas. Portions are hearty, the wine list is approachable, and it strikes a nice balance between “special night out” and “comfortable regular spot.”

Best for:

  • Italian date night without driving into KC
  • Pasta and wine with friends
  • Pre‑ or post‑event dinners near the Square

5. Up Dog

Up Dog is a fun, ultra‑casual Independence original that leans into retro hot‑dog‑stand nostalgia. It’s small, bright, and diner‑like—order at the counter, grab a seat, and watch locals stream in and out.

The specialty here is hot dogs and sausages with lots of topping options—chili dogs, Chicago‑style, Kansas City‑style, or fully loaded creations. You’ll also usually find burgers, Polish sausages, Frito pies, and classic sides like tater tots, onion rings, and shakes. It’s inexpensive, quick, and a nice alternative to chain fast food.

Best for:

  • Quick, kid‑friendly meals
  • A fun, nostalgic hot dog and fries fix
  • Casual lunches while exploring Independence

Get the All-American Travel Secrets!

Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!

Leave a Comment