Colorado Springs has plenty of well-known chains and big “event” restaurants, but the best meals often live in smaller rooms.
If you venture into Old Colorado City, the Westside, and pockets near downtown, you’ll find a more personal dining scene.
A lot of the strongest spots here focus on consistency and hospitality rather than hype.
That makes them perfect for visitors who want something local and for locals who want a dependable favorite.
Here are nine underrated restaurants in Colorado Springs that are worth your time.
1) The Rabbit Hole (Downtown)
The Rabbit Hole feels like a little escape, with a cozy, subterranean setting that makes dinner feel like an occasion.
The menu leans New American and playful without being confusing.
It’s a strong pick when you want a fun atmosphere but still want the food to hold up.
Bring a group that likes sharing, because ordering a few things across the menu is where it shines.
If you’re going on a weekend, build in a little extra time because it can get busy.
2) Shuga’s (Downtown)
Shuga’s has a quirky, beloved vibe that still manages to feel underrated to people who haven’t spent much time in the city.
The menu is eclectic in a way that somehow works, which makes it great for mixed cravings.
It’s a solid lunch choice, but it’s also a surprisingly satisfying casual dinner.
If you like meals that feel a bit like comfort food with personality, you’ll be happy here.
Take a moment to actually read the menu, because the best orders aren’t always obvious at first glance.
3) Uchenna Ethiopian Restaurant (Near Downtown)
Uchenna is the kind of place that turns dinner into a shared experience, not just a meal.
The flavors are deep and warming, and the platters are naturally designed for a table to split.
It’s an excellent option when you want something different from the typical Springs rotation.
Go hungry and commit to eating with your hands, because that’s part of the fun.
If you’re new to Ethiopian food, ask for a mix that includes both mild and spicy options.
4) Monse’s Taste of El Salvador (East Colorado Springs)
Monse’s is a casual, family-run spot that delivers big comfort with zero pretension.
It’s a great reminder that some of the best meals come from the most modest dining rooms.
If you’ve never had Salvadoran food, this is a friendly place to start.
Bring an appetite and don’t be afraid to order more than one item to sample.
If you’re picking up takeout, it travels well and makes a great “next-day lunch.”
5) Red Gravy (Old Colorado City)
Red Gravy is a cozy Italian option that feels built for repeat visits.
The room has an easy warmth that fits the neighborhood perfectly.
You come here when you want something satisfying and straightforward, done with care.
It’s especially good for a relaxed date night where you can actually hear each other talk.
If you’re deciding between dishes, lean toward whatever feels most comforting that day.
6) Jake and Telly’s Greek Taverna (Old Colorado City)
Jake and Telly’s is a longtime local favorite that still surprises newcomers.
The menu has plenty of crowd-pleasers, but the overall experience feels more personal than the typical “theme” restaurant.
It’s a great place for groups because everyone can build a meal that suits them.
If you want the full experience, order a few shareables and make it a leisurely dinner.
Go with a mindset of “warm hospitality first,” because that’s a big part of the charm.
7) Four by Brother Luck (Downtown)
Four is chef-driven and intimate, which makes it a good choice when you want a more curated experience.
It’s a place where the kitchen’s point of view matters, and the food reflects that.
If you like tasting your way through a meal rather than ordering one big plate, this fits the bill.
It’s especially rewarding if you enjoy seasonal cooking and thoughtful presentation.
Consider it for celebrations when you want something special without a big-city attitude.
8) Piglatin Cocina (Downtown)
Piglatin is energetic, bold, and built for flavor-forward meals.
The menu has a playful edge, which keeps it from feeling like the same dinner you can get anywhere.
It’s a great stop when you want something that pairs well with a fun drink order.
Bring friends who like sharing, because it’s more fun when the table becomes a sampler.
If you like heat, there are usually options that lean spicy in a satisfying way.
9) Cerberus Brewing Company (Downtown)
Cerberus is known for beer, but it deserves more credit as a “dinner place.”
The food is far better than the usual brewery baseline, which makes it an easy recommendation.
It works well for low-key nights when you still want a meal that feels complete.
If your group is split between “food people” and “beer people,” it’s a clean compromise.
Show up a bit before peak hours if you want the most relaxed experience.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
