5 Underrated San Mateo, California Restaurants that Are Absolutely Worth Trying

Located in the heart of the San Francisco Peninsula, San Mateo boasts a bustling downtown with a culinary scene that is as diverse and dynamic as any in the Bay Area. While it might not have the same name recognition as San Francisco or Oakland, locals know it’s a treasure trove of authentic, high-quality restaurants, especially when it comes to Japanese cuisine.

To truly experience San Mateo’s food culture, you need to dive into the vibrant blocks of its downtown and explore the neighborhood gems that line its streets. Here are five underrated restaurants that showcase why San Mateo is a premier dining destination.

1. Ramen Dojo

Be prepared to wait in line, because Ramen Dojo is a legend among ramen aficionados. This tiny, cash-only shop specializes in rich, spicy ramen that is absolutely worth the wait. You have your choice of soy, miso, or garlic-pork broth, and a heat level from “no spicy” to “extra spicy.” The space is intimate and intense, focused solely on delivering one of the best and most satisfying bowls of ramen in the Bay Area.

2. Pausa Bar & Cookery

A chic and stylish addition to downtown San Mateo, Pausa brings modern Italian cuisine to the Peninsula. The restaurant features a stunning interior, an open kitchen, and a vibrant bar. The menu centers on house-made pasta, artisanal pizza, and expertly prepared entrees. It’s a place that feels both celebratory and comfortable, perfect for a date night or a sophisticated meal with friends.

3. Tanto

For an authentic Japanese izakaya (pub) experience, Tanto is the place to be. This lively spot is perfect for sharing small plates and drinks with friends. The menu is extensive, featuring everything from perfectly grilled yakitori skewers and fresh sashimi to unique small dishes and comforting noodle soups. The atmosphere is energetic and always packed with a Japanese-speaking clientele, a sure sign of its authenticity.

4. Gao Viet Kitchen

Gao Viet Kitchen takes traditional Vietnamese dishes and gives them a bold, modern, and often massive twist. This spot is famous for its “Gao-normous Pho,” a gigantic bowl of pho that could feed a small family, as well as its garlic noodles served with giant grilled prawns. The flavors are intense, the portions are generous, and the vibe is fun and high-energy.

5. 31st Union

Located just off the main drag, 31st Union is a cozy, rustic restaurant focused on seasonal, farm-to-table Californian cuisine. The menu is concise and changes regularly to reflect the freshest available ingredients. It’s a neighborhood spot with a lot of heart, offering beautifully crafted dishes, a great selection of craft beer and wine, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.