Pueblo is a city with a gritty, industrial past and a fiercely proud culinary heritage.
The food scene is defined by its famous chiles, historic Italian community, and the invention of the “Slopper.”
The best food here is served in decades-old taverns, markets, and family-run restaurants where tradition is everything.
To eat in Pueblo is to taste the history of Southern Colorado.
Here are five no-frills restaurants in Pueblo that serve the best food you’ll ever taste.
1. Gray’s Coors Tavern
Gray’s is a legendary Pueblo dive bar and one of the original homes of the “Slopper.”
This iconic local dish is an open-faced cheeseburger smothered in fiery Pueblo green chili.
Eating a Slopper at the bar in this historic tavern is a quintessential, must-do Pueblo experience.
2. Gagliano’s Italian Market & Deli
Operating for over 100 years, Gagliano’s is a living piece of Pueblo’s Italian history.
This small market and deli makes incredible sandwiches using their own homemade sausage and imported Italian goods.
The “Dagwood” sandwich is a local legend, a masterpiece of meat and cheese that is worth a pilgrimage.
3. Pass Key Restaurant
Pass Key is another Pueblo institution, famous for its iconic Italian sausage sandwich, known locally as a “Pass Key.”
This family-run spot has been serving its signature sandwich on a crunchy torpedo roll for decades.
It’s a simple, perfect, and uniquely Pueblo meal.
4. Rita’s Mexican Food Restaurant
Rita’s is an old-school, beloved Mexican restaurant that has been serving the community for generations.
The decor is simple and dated, but the food is timeless, especially the crispy, stuffed sopapillas and red chile.
This is authentic, home-style Mexican cooking at its finest.
5. Do Drop Inn
The Do Drop Inn is a legendary local pizza parlor, famous for its unique, square-cut pizzas.
It’s a bustling, family-friendly spot that hasn’t changed much over the years, and that’s why people love it.
This is where generations of Puebloans have gone for a celebratory pizza night.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
