In Columbus, the fry scene is surprisingly competitive. From iconic burger joints to trendy taverns and neighborhood cafes, locals know exactly where to go when they want fries done right. Some restaurants focus on classic pub-style baskets, while others elevate fries with gourmet toppings and house-made sauces. Either way, these five spots consistently rank among the city’s favorites.
1. Thurman Cafe
The Thurman Cafe is famous for massive burgers, but locals know the thick-cut fries deserve equal attention. Crispy on the outside with hearty potato texture inside, they’re built to stand up to the restaurant’s oversized menu items.
What makes them memorable is their old-school tavern quality. There’s nothing overly trendy about them — just well-executed fries served hot and generously portioned. Regulars often pair them with burgers stacked so high they barely fit on the plate.
The laid-back atmosphere and decades-long reputation only add to the experience, making Thurman Cafe a true Columbus institution.
2. Northstar Cafe
Northstar Cafe takes a cleaner, more refined approach to fries, and locals absolutely love it. Their shoestring fries are crisp, light, and consistently addictive without feeling greasy or heavy.
Many customers appreciate the balance between freshness and simplicity. The fries arrive perfectly salted and pair surprisingly well with the restaurant’s more health-conscious menu options.
They’ve become especially popular among diners who want fries that feel elevated while still delivering the comfort and satisfaction everyone expects.
3. Bareburger
Bareburger has earned a loyal following thanks in large part to its outstanding fry selection. The truffle fries are especially popular, delivering rich flavor, parmesan, and herbs without overwhelming the crisp texture.
Sweet potato fries also receive consistent praise from Columbus locals who appreciate their balance of sweetness and crunch. With multiple dipping sauces available, many diners turn the fries into a full experience rather than just a side dish.
The restaurant’s modern atmosphere and customizable menu have helped make it one of the city’s favorite burger destinations.
4. Press Grill
Press Grill serves exactly the kind of classic pub fries people crave late at night. Crisp, salty, and reliably satisfying, they’ve become a staple among downtown regulars.
The fries pair especially well with burgers and cold beer, which explains why so many locals stop in during sporting events and weekend evenings. Their texture consistently earns praise, maintaining crunch without drying out.
For many Columbus residents, Press Grill represents the perfect combination of neighborhood tavern atmosphere and dependable comfort food.
5. Arch City Tavern
Arch City Tavern has built a strong reputation around indulgent comfort food, and the fries are a huge reason why. Loaded fry baskets topped with cheese, bacon, and sauces are especially popular among the late-night crowd.
Even the standard fries stand out thanks to their crispy exterior and flavorful seasoning. The portions are large enough for sharing, though many customers quickly decide against it after the first few bites.
The lively atmosphere and hearty menu make Arch City Tavern one of the city’s favorite places for casual comfort food done extremely well.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
