Colorado Springs tends to live in Denver’s culinary shadow, which is a shame — and frankly, an opportunity for anyone willing to look past the tourist traps near Garden of the Gods.
The city’s best meals are happening in unassuming storefronts, family-run kitchens, and neighborhoods that most visitors never see.
Here are five spots that locals quietly love.
1. Hidalgo’s Kitchen — Hole-in-the-Wall Mexican Done Right
📍 Colorado Springs, CO
Don’t let the no-frills exterior fool you. Hidalgo’s Kitchen is the kind of Mexican restaurant that Colorado Springs residents mention in hushed, possessive tones — like a discovery they’re not entirely sure they want to share.
The menu is rooted in the kind of honest, from-scratch Mexican cooking that most cities only pretend to have.
The chile rellenos are the move here — stuffed, battered, and sauced with a depth of flavor that’s hard to find outside of someone’s abuela’s kitchen. Everything is made with care rather than speed, which means the wait is sometimes longer than you’d expect. Order anyway. It’s worth it every time.
2. Jake & Telly’s Greek Taverna — A Colorado Springs Institution
📍 2616 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs (Old Colorado City)
Tucked into the charming stretch of Old Colorado City, Jake & Telly’s has been a local anchor for decades — and yet first-timers almost always react with some version of “how did I not know about this place?”
The answer is that it doesn’t need to advertise. Word of mouth has kept it packed for years.
The lamb dishes are the heart of the menu, slow-cooked and seasoned with the kind of restraint that lets the quality of the meat speak for itself. The spanakopita is crispy, buttery, and made in-house.
The atmosphere feels genuinely Mediterranean — warm, loud in the best way, and full of families that have been coming here for generations. In a city full of chain restaurants, Jake & Telly’s is a reminder of what a neighborhood restaurant is supposed to feel like.
3. The Burrowing Owl — Brunch Worth Setting an Alarm For
📍 2445 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs
The line outside The Burrowing Owl on a weekend morning is the first sign you’re onto something.
This cozy, eccentric brunch spot has developed a cult following in Colorado Springs for its creative takes on morning food — think dishes that go well beyond eggs and toast without veering into the kind of gimmickry that makes brunch insufferable.
The green chile eggs benedict is a Colorado classic executed at peak form. The breakfast burritos are stuffed to the point of structural concern and come smothered in house-made green or red chile.
Coffee is serious here too — not an afterthought. It’s the kind of place where you linger for two hours without noticing, which is exactly the right pace for a Saturday morning in the Springs.
4. Shuga’s — Coffee Bar by Day, Cocktail Den by Night
📍 702 S Cascade Ave, Colorado Springs
Shuga’s is one of those rare places that genuinely works as both a daytime café and an evening cocktail destination — which makes it feel like two different restaurants depending on when you walk in.
Located in a beautifully restored building near downtown, it has a warmth and personality that most new-build restaurants spend a fortune trying to fake.
During the day, the house-made pastries and espresso drinks anchor a menu built for slow mornings and working lunches.
After dark, the cocktail list takes over — creative, well-balanced, and priced fairly. The fig and brie flatbread is a perennial favourite that bridges both worlds. For a city that’s still building its food identity, Shuga’s is already a landmark.
5. Uwe’s German Restaurant — The Most Underrated Cuisine in the City
📍 Colorado Springs, CO
German food in Colorado Springs is not something you’d think to seek out — which is precisely why Uwe’s has a devoted following of people who stumbled in once and never stopped coming back.
This family-run restaurant is as authentic as it gets outside of Munich, with recipes that clearly haven’t been Americanized into blandness.
The schnitzel is pounded thin, breaded perfectly, and served with sides that match its quality. The sauerbraten — a slow-braised pot roast marinated in a tangy, sweet-sour sauce — is one of the most deeply satisfying dishes in the entire city. Portions are enormous. Service is warm and personal. If you want a meal that feels nothing like anything else you’ve had in Colorado Springs, this is the one.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
