Reading’s food scene reflects Pennsylvania comfort, Latin American influence, old-school diners, bakeries, and family restaurants that rarely shout for attention. The best hidden gems here are casual, generous, and rooted in the city’s neighborhoods.
These five off-the-beaten-path Reading restaurants are worth finding.
1. Judy’s on Cherry
Judy’s on Cherry is a long-loved Reading restaurant in a historic setting, serving Mediterranean-leaning American dishes, wood-fired flavors, and a warm dining room. It feels like a special-occasion spot without losing local charm.
Expect grilled meats, seafood, pasta, salads, and thoughtful plates. Judy’s is a strong pick when you want Reading dining to feel a little elevated.
2. Mi Casa Su Casa Cafe
Mi Casa Su Casa Cafe brings Latin comfort and community warmth to Reading, with food that feels personal and welcoming. It is the kind of spot that lives up to its name.
Order rice plates, sandwiches, empanadas, soups, or whatever house specialties are available. Mi Casa Su Casa is casual, friendly, and full of neighborhood energy.
3. Frank & Diannah’s Arbor Inn
Frank & Diannah’s Arbor Inn is a tucked-away local favorite with comfort food, steaks, seafood, and a classic dining-room atmosphere. It is the kind of place regulars appreciate because it feels consistent.
Come for dinner when you want something hearty and familiar. The Arbor Inn is old-school in a way that still matters.
4. Cafe Folino
Cafe Folino is a family-run Italian restaurant in the Reading area serving pasta, pizza, sauces, and classic Italian-American comfort. It is casual enough for an easy dinner but satisfying enough to feel like more than takeout.
Order pasta, chicken dishes, or a pizza for the table. Cafe Folino is a solid neighborhood Italian option with real staying power.
5. Screpesi’s Sandwich Shop
Screpesi’s is a Reading-area sandwich institution known for Italian sandwiches, rolls, meats, and straightforward local flavor. It is not fancy, and it should not be.
Go for a classic hoagie or Italian sandwich and appreciate a place built on doing one thing well. Screpesi’s is Reading comfort between bread.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
