5 Best Pizza Places in Cincinnati to Try Today

Cincinnati’s pizza scene is thriving, thanks to a mix of classic neighborhood favorites, adventurous new pizzerias, and some uniquely regional styles.

From Dayton-inspired squares to stuffed pies and New York–style slices, Queen City pizza lovers have some seriously delicious options.

Here are the five best pizza places in Cincinnati for 2025:

1. Angilo’s Pizza

Angilo’s is an institution for good reason. Known for their legendary Dayton-style pizza—rectangular, thin, and cut into squares with toppings edge to edge—Angilo’s delivers consistently crispy, salty, and satisfying pies.

The crust is slightly floury underneath thanks to a dusting of cornmeal, and there’s an impressive range of toppings.

Angilo’s is also renowned for fast delivery, making it the city’s go-to for a quick, classic pizza fix.

2. Luca Pizza di Roma

Craving a hearty pizza with a twist? Luca Pizza di Roma is the top destination for stuffed pizza in Cincinnati.

Their signature pies feature a double layer of fresh dough packed with cheese and fillings that bake up golden and gooey.

Fans rave about their authentic NY-style slices and the ability to customize fillings—making each visit a deliciously unique experience.

3. Happy’s Pizza

When you’re in the mood for something thick and indulgent, Happy’s Pizza is the place for Cincinnati’s best deep-dish pizza.

Their “Deep Dish Everything” is loaded with all available toppings and built to impress even the hungriest diner.

The crust is buttery and crisp, holding up to generous layers of sauce, cheese, and toppings for a meal that’s equal parts comfort and flavor.

4. Andy’s Mediterranean Grill

Andy’s Mediterranean Grill takes the city’s veggie pizza crown and offers one of Cincinnati’s most unique pizza experiences.

Here, you can enjoy Italian, Spanish, Greek, and Lebanese pizzas—all with hand-tossed dough made fresh in-house.

Whether you’re vegetarian or seeking bold Mediterranean flavors (like falafel or kebab alongside feta and olives), Andy’s delivers creative fusion pies you won’t find anywhere else.

5. Fireside Pizza

A beloved local favorite, Fireside Pizza is celebrated for its wood-fired pies boasting a perfectly crispy, slightly charred crust and fresh, thoughtful toppings.

Their menu blends traditional Italian flavors with creative specials, and every pizza is cooked to order in a welcoming, laid-back setting.

Fireside is ideal for pizza purists and anyone looking to enjoy high-quality ingredients in a relaxed atmosphere.