5 Best Pizza Places in Dewitt, Iowa to Try

DeWitt combines small town charm, agricultural heritage, and authentic Eastern Iowa character.

Here’s where locals find their favorite pizza in 2025.

1. Matthiesen’s Arcade & Pizza

This DeWitt institution has been serving hand-tossed pies and entertainment to generations of locals, becoming as much a community center as a pizzeria.

Their slightly sweet sauce and perfect crust with generous toppings create that nostalgic flavor that families have enjoyed for decades.

2. Lincoln Park Pizza Company

Named for DeWitt’s central green space, this downtown favorite fires artisanal pies in a beautiful brick oven within a renovated historic building that contributes to the town’s charming main street.

Their naturally leavened dough develops complex flavor through extended fermentation, while seasonal ingredients from nearby farms create distinctive combinations that showcase Eastern Iowa agricultural bounty.

3. Highway 30 Pizza & Pub

This roadside favorite combines quality pies with lively sports bar atmosphere in a concept perfectly positioned on DeWitt’s main transportation route.

Their hand-tossed crusts support generous toppings at reasonable prices, while multiple screens make this the natural gathering spot for watching Iowa and Iowa State games.

The casual, welcoming environment attracts diverse customers from farmers to factory workers to families, creating a true cross-section of DeWitt society.

4. DeWitt Family Pizza & Buffet

This practical favorite delivers consistent quality with an all-you-can-eat format that respects DeWitt’s value-conscious, family-oriented character.

Their medium-thick crust supports various toppings with new pizzas constantly emerging from the kitchen to keep the buffet fresh and diverse.

The spacious, kid-friendly environment makes this perfect for team celebrations and family gatherings where different preferences can all be satisfied.

5. Farm & Flame Wood Fired Pizza

This mobile wood-fired operation brings exceptional pizza to DeWitt events, farmers markets, and private gatherings.

Their portable Italian oven creates perfectly charred crusts topped with ingredients sourced from surrounding Clinton County farms.

The “DeWitt Community Garden” featuring seasonal produce supports local growing initiatives while showcasing the best of Iowa’s agricultural bounty.