5 Burger Spots in Tustin, California that Locals are Raving About

Tustin sits right between Irvine and Santa Ana, and locals have plenty of burger options that aren’t just big chains. These are the standouts.

1. Peter’s Gourmade Grill

Originally a gas‑station‑adjacent spot, now a beloved burger destination.

Burgers here are juicy and flavorful, with toppings like grilled onions, avocado, bacon, and house sauces. The buns are soft and slightly sweet, and the fries (especially the loaded or “gourmade” versions) are a must. It feels homey and a little quirky—in the best way.

2. The Black Marlin

Seafood‑leaning restaurant in Old Town Tustin that also does a standout burger.

The house burger is typically a thick patty with cheddar or jack, lettuce, tomato, onion, and maybe bacon or aioli on a toasted bun. It’s the kind of burger you order with a beer or cocktail on the patio and feel like you scored.

3. In‑N‑Out Burger (Tustin)

Yes, it’s a chain. Yes, locals still swear by it.

Double‑Double, Animal Style, grilled onions, extra spread—the formula is famous for a reason. Thin patties, fresh toppings, and those soft buns make it a go‑to for a quick, reliable burger fix.

4. The American Grub

Casual spot that leans into classic American comfort food, burgers front and center.

Burgers are substantial and cooked to order, with choices like bacon‑cheddar, blue cheese and caramelized onion, or spicy jalapeño builds. They come with plenty of fries, and the whole place feels like a modern diner/bar hybrid.

5. Lucille’s Smokehouse BBQ (bar burger)

BBQ first, but the burger holds its own.

You’ll get a smoky, juicy patty—sometimes topped with pulled pork or brisket—plus cheese, BBQ sauce, and all the usual fixings on a toasted bun. It’s over‑the‑top in a very satisfying way.