Indianapolis is a deeply hardworking, fiercely independent Midwestern capital that boasts a culinary scene heavily anchored in old-school tradition, sincere community pride, and surprisingly sophisticated modern artistry.
While the city is most famously known for the Indy 500 and its massive sports culture, locals here take their frozen treats incredibly seriously. When the muggy, sweltering Indiana summer heat finally rolls in, the demand for high-quality ice cream skyrockets, and the Circle City absolutely delivers.
Indy’s ice cream scene is brilliantly diverse, spanning everything from deeply nostalgic, decades-old neighborhood parlors to highly innovative, chef-driven modern creameries crafting wildly experimental flavors. The locals here completely shun generic corporate scoop shops in favor of fiercely independent, deeply community-rooted operations. If you want to escape the chains and eat exactly where true Hoosiers spend their summer evenings, you absolutely must explore these five spectacular, highly beloved local ice cream destinations.
1. Lick Ice Cream
If there is one undisputed darling of the modern Indianapolis dessert scene, it is absolutely Lick Ice Cream. With locations in the vibrant Garfield Park neighborhood and the bustling AMP at 16 Tech Innovation District, Lick has completely redefined what artisanal, small-batch ice cream looks like in central Indiana. The operation is fiercely independent, deeply passionate, and entirely uncompromising in its commitment to high-quality ingredients.
Every single base at Lick is made completely from scratch, using locally sourced Indiana dairy and meticulously curated mix-ins. The flavor board is constantly rotating, featuring everything from deeply classic, perfectly executed staples to wildly experimental seasonal creations. You absolutely must try their legendary Brown Butter Almond Brittle, a flawless, deeply nutty masterpiece, or their highly innovative Strawberry Basil when summer Indiana berries are in peak season. The texture is staggeringly dense, impossibly creamy, and perfectly balanced. Pair a massive scoop with one of their freshly pressed waffle cones, and you have an absolutely essential modern Indianapolis culinary experience.
2. BRICS
Tucked deeply into the historic, vibrant Lockerbie Square neighborhood just east of downtown, BRICS is a completely charming, deeply nostalgic, and fiercely beloved local ice cream parlor that perfectly anchors one of Indianapolis’s most beautiful old-school communities. The shop occupies a stunning, classically renovated historic building, and stepping inside feels exactly like walking directly into the absolute best, most carefree days of a 1950s Indiana summer.
BRICS (which stands for Brian’s Really Incredible Cones and Sundaes) operates on a deeply uncompromising philosophy: every single flavor is made in small batches using high-quality dairy and authentic, meticulously sourced ingredients. The flavor rotation leans heavily into deeply nostalgic, perfectly executed classics: an impossibly rich Salted Caramel, a flawless Mint Chocolate Chip, and a legendary Black Cherry that has anchored countless local summer afternoons. The patio out front, shaded by historic Lockerbie trees, is the absolute perfect spot to enjoy a massive scoop while watching the neighborhood drift by. It is a deeply comforting, completely essential Indianapolis tradition.
3. The Best Chocolate in Town
For an absolutely unique, deeply sophisticated, and intensely flavorful culinary experience, you absolutely have to make the pilgrimage to The Best Chocolate in Town, located in the vibrant Mass Ave Arts District. While the shop is famously known across Indianapolis for crafting some of the most incredible, hand-dipped artisan chocolates in the entire Midwest, the deeply guarded local secret is that they also produce some of the most flawless, intensely flavored small-batch ice creams in the city.
Owner Elizabeth Garber crafts the ice cream completely in-house, using the exact same uncompromising commitment to high-quality ingredients that defines her legendary chocolate operation. The flavors are deep, intensely complex, and completely devoid of any artificial shortcuts. You absolutely must try their staggeringly rich Dark Chocolate (made with their own house-crafted ganache), their flawless Salted Caramel, or their highly innovative seasonal creations. Pair a massive scoop with a hand-dipped truffle or a freshly made chocolate-covered strawberry, and you have an absolutely sophisticated, deeply elevated Indianapolis dessert experience.
4. Nicey Treat
While technically built on the foundation of artisan paletas rather than traditional scooped ice cream, no honest, deeply researched guide to Indianapolis frozen treats would be complete without massive, deep respect for Nicey Treat. This fiercely independent, deeply beloved local operation has completely revolutionized the popsicle and frozen treat game in central Indiana. Their charming, brightly colored shops have anchored countless summer afternoons across the city.
What makes Nicey Treat absolutely essential is their deeply uncompromising commitment to fresh, locally sourced, completely natural ingredients. Every single pop is crafted by hand using real Indiana fruit, organic dairy, and meticulously curated mix-ins. They split their massive flavor rotation between intensely refreshing fruity pops (the Strawberry Lemonade is an absolute summer masterpiece) and impossibly creamy, ice-cream-style pops (the Cookies and Cream is staggeringly indulgent). The flavors rotate constantly based on what is fresh from local Indiana farms. It is a fun, deeply affordable, and consistently flawless modern Hoosier treat.
5. Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream
Rounding out the list is a deeply unpretentious, highly nostalgic, and completely beloved hidden gem located in the northern suburb of Carmel. Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream is the absolute quintessential old-school neighborhood scoop shop, completely devoid of pretense and intensely focused on serving incredible, deeply comforting frozen treats to a fiercely loyal local community.
The ice cream program at Sundaes operates on a deeply simple, beautiful philosophy: every flavor is made completely from scratch in small batches, using high-quality dairy and authentic ingredients. The texture is impossibly dense, wildly creamy, and packed with deep, perfectly balanced sweetness. The flavor rotation leans heavily into deeply classic, perfectly executed staples: an incredibly rich Cookies and Cream, a flawless Vanilla Bean, and a legendary Cake Batter that has anchored countless Carmel birthday parties. The shop itself is brightly lit, deeply welcoming, and constantly buzzing with multi-generational families. It is a fast, highly affordable, and consistently flawless Indianapolis tradition.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
