Appleton sits along the Fox River in northeast Wisconsin, a city that most people associate with paper mills, Lawrence University, and (if they’re Packers fans) its proximity to Green Bay.
What they don’t know is that Appleton has developed a restaurant scene that’s genuinely impressive, driven by passionate chefs who’ve chosen to build their careers here instead of in bigger cities.
The result is a collection of restaurants that feel personal and community-rooted in a way that’s hard to find in more saturated markets. Here are five that are worth the drive.
1. Ellinor
An upscale, casual restaurant in an Appleton neighborhood, perfect for any occasion.
At the center of Ellinor’s open kitchen lies a wood-fired oven, where each course starts.
They take pride in using local ingredients, building relationships with nearby farmers and producers to support the community and create unique dishes that couldn’t exist anywhere else.
Ellinor is the kind of restaurant that makes you realize Appleton is playing at a higher level than you expected.
The wood-fired flavors permeate everything, the seasonal menu keeps things interesting, and the atmosphere strikes that perfect balance between refined and approachable. It’s where Appleton goes to impress out-of-town guests, and it never disappoints.
2. Jones & Co
A refined yet welcoming wine and cocktail lounge nestled in Downtown Appleton, serving scratch-made food with a focus on handmade pasta and gnocchi, alongside classic craft cocktails, curated wines, and pantry goods.
It’s a place to dine, drink, and shop: where every detail speaks to quality, comfort, and charm.
The atmosphere exudes warmth and sophistication, inviting guests to slow down, sip, and savor. Jones & Co is the kind of place you didn’t know Appleton needed until it opened, and now you can’t imagine the downtown scene without it. The handmade pasta alone is worth the visit, and the cocktail program shows a level of care that rivals much larger cities.
3. Carmella’s & VIA
Carmella’s serves refined Italian bistro dining rooted in family tradition during dinner service, with thoughtfully curated dishes made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients. But the real hidden gem might be VIA, its sister concept in the same space: a bold, street-style Naples-inspired spot serving Neapolitan pizzas, fresh seasonal salads, and homemade gelato made from local grass-fed milk (no cream).
Two Italian dining experiences under one roof, each with its own personality. Carmella’s for when you want white tablecloth elegance, VIA for when you want to feel like you’re eating on a Naples side street. The gelato at VIA is genuinely some of the best you’ll find in the Midwest, and the fact that it’s made with local grass-fed milk gives it a richness that imported alternatives can’t match.
4. Mad Elephant Thai & Fusion
Offering cuisine, togetherness, and joy since 2023, Mad Elephant has quickly become Appleton’s go-to for Thai and Asian fusion. The chef crafts seasonal menus with the freshest ingredients and inventive flavors, and the restaurant’s commitment to creating a remarkable dining experience shows in every detail.
In a city where Thai food options were limited, Mad Elephant filled a void with style and substance. The flavors are bold, the presentation is beautiful, and the space has a modern energy that feels fresh. It’s the kind of restaurant that signals a city’s food scene is growing up, and Appleton is clearly better for its presence.
5. Mondo! on the River
A restaurant along the banks of the Fox River with stunning views of the dam and water birds, Mondo! serves house-made pastas, sandwiches on house-made focaccia, entrées, and more. The wine list is carefully curated to pair with the seasonally changing menu, and the setting is genuinely gorgeous.
There’s something about eating house-made pasta while watching the river flow that elevates even a Tuesday dinner into something memorable. Mondo! doesn’t try to be fancy; it just does everything with care and lets the setting do the rest. Reservations are available for parties up to 12, and bar seats are always first come, first served. Either way, you’re eating well with a view.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
