Rochester’s unique culinary claim to fame is the “Garbage Plate,” a dish that is the pinnacle of no-frills eating.
The city’s food scene is built on this iconic dish, along with classic drive-ins and old-fashioned sub shops.
These are the places that have been feeding the community for decades with hearty, unpretentious food.
To understand Rochester, you must first understand the beauty of the Garbage Plate.
Here are five no-frills restaurants in Rochester that serve the best food you’ll ever taste.
1. Nick Tahou Hots
This is the legendary birthplace of the Garbage Plate.
The original Nick Tahou’s is a gritty, historic spot that has been serving its signature creation for over a century.
A true Garbage Plate consists of a base of home fries and macaroni salad, topped with your choice of meats (like cheeseburgers or hot dogs), and finished with mustard, onions, and a spicy meat sauce.
It’s a messy, delicious, and essential Rochester experience.
2. Dogtown Hots
Dogtown takes the classic Rochester “hot” (hot dog) and elevates it with creative, high-quality ingredients.
This quirky, narrow spot serves a huge variety of hot dogs and sausages, along with their own excellent version of the Garbage Plate.
It’s a fun, modern take on a classic Rochester tradition.
The focus is on quality and flavor in a distinctly casual setting.
3. DiBella’s Old Fashioned Submarines
Before it became a regional chain, DiBella’s was a corner bakery and sub shop in Rochester.
The original locations still have that old-school charm, serving incredible subs on their signature fresh-baked, seeded bread.
The Godfather is a classic combination of Italian meats that is simple and perfect.
It’s the submarine sandwich all others are measured against.
4. Don’s Original
Don’s Original is a classic American drive-in that has been a Rochester staple since 1945.
It’s a throwback spot serving great burgers, ground steak sandwiches, and their own take on the plate.
Their frozen custard is also legendary.
It’s a perfect slice of mid-century Americana.
5. Schaller’s Drive-In
Another beloved Rochester drive-in, Schaller’s has been serving the community since 1956.
With its classic neon sign and carhop-era architecture, it’s a true landmark.
They are known for their white hots, burgers, and fantastic onion rings.
It’s a family-friendly institution that represents the city’s culinary history.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
