Indianapolis has long lived in the shadow of Chicago when it comes to Midwest food conversations.
But that’s a mistake — Indy’s restaurant scene has been on a serious upswing, with a wave of talented chefs, creative concepts, and passionate small-business owners transforming the city into a legitimate food destination.
Beyond the well-known steakhouses and downtown establishments that fill up on race weekends, there’s a deep bench of underrated restaurants doing incredible work without the spotlight.
We’ve done the legwork so you don’t have to. Here are nine underrated restaurants in Indianapolis that deserve a spot on your must-try list.
1. Tinker Street
Tucked into the Broad Ripple neighborhood, Tinker Street is a farm-to-table gem that deserves far more recognition than it gets.
The menu changes frequently based on seasonal availability, but expect dishes that are creative, beautifully plated, and deeply rooted in local ingredients — think seared duck breast with seasonal vegetables, handmade pastas, and inventive small plates.
The space itself feels intimate and warm, with exposed brick and soft lighting that creates the perfect atmosphere for a date night or a special occasion.
It’s the kind of restaurant that makes you feel like you’ve stumbled onto something truly special.
2. Mama Irma’s Kitchen
For authentic Latin American comfort food in Indianapolis, Mama Irma’s Kitchen is the real deal.
This family-owned spot on the east side of town serves up Guatemalan and Mexican dishes that are prepared with obvious love and tradition — the tamales are handmade, the pupusas are perfectly crispy on the outside and pillowy inside, and the horchata is some of the best you’ll find anywhere.
The restaurant is small and unassuming, which is exactly why so many people drive right past it without knowing what they’re missing.
Once you try it, though, you’ll be back — that’s a promise.
3. Siam Square
Indianapolis has a surprisingly robust Thai food scene, and Siam Square sits right at the top of it.
Located on the near east side, this no-frills restaurant serves up authentic Thai dishes with bold, unapologetic flavors — the pad kra pao is fiery and fragrant, the green curry is perfectly balanced, and the som tum papaya salad has just the right amount of funk and heat.
The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and they’ll adjust the spice level to your preference — though we recommend going at least one level higher than you think you can handle.
Siam Square is a must-visit for anyone who takes their Thai food seriously.
4. Beholder
Beholder is one of those restaurants that’s almost impossible to categorize — and that’s part of what makes it so great.
Located in the Fountain Square neighborhood, this eclectic spot from chef Jonathan Brooks features a constantly evolving menu that draws from global influences while staying rooted in seasonal Midwestern ingredients.
One visit might feature a stunning beef tartare, while the next could surprise you with a creative vegetable-forward dish that completely redefines what you thought was possible with a simple beet or carrot.
The cocktail program is equally inventive, and the moody, intimate atmosphere makes every meal feel like an event.
5. Amelia’s Bakery and Noodle Shop
Amelia’s is a delightful contradiction — a bakery and noodle shop rolled into one — and it works beautifully.
By day, you’ll find some of the city’s best pastries, breads, and baked goods lining the counter, each one crafted with precision and care.
But it’s the noodle dishes that have developed a cult following — rich, handmade bowls of ramen and other Asian-inspired noodle soups that are deeply comforting and surprisingly complex.
It’s an unexpected combination in an unexpected location, and it’s exactly the kind of place that makes Indianapolis’s food scene so exciting.
6. Cholita Tacos
Indy’s taco scene is more competitive than most people realize, and Cholita Tacos is one of its brightest stars.
This laid-back spot in Broad Ripple serves up Peruvian-inspired tacos and street food that bring something genuinely different to the table — think lomo saltado tacos, aji amarillo crema, and fresh ceviche that rivals what you’d find on the coast.
The flavors are vibrant, the portions are generous, and the prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality you’re getting.
If your idea of tacos begins and ends with ground beef and shredded cheese, Cholita is about to change your world.
7. Babbs Supermarket Coffee Shop
This one might sound strange, but hear us out — inside Babbs Supermarket on the south side of Indianapolis is a tiny coffee shop and kitchen that serves some of the best homestyle breakfast and lunch in the city.
The biscuits and gravy are legendary among those in the know, the fried tenderloin is a perfect Indiana classic, and the prices feel like they haven’t changed since the 1990s.
It’s about as far from a trendy food destination as you can get, and that’s exactly what makes it so special.
You eat at the counter, you chat with the regulars, and you leave feeling like you’ve discovered one of Indy’s best-kept secrets — because you have.
8. Abyssinia Ethiopian Restaurant
Abyssinia has been quietly serving some of Indianapolis’s best Ethiopian food for years, and it remains criminally underrated.
The injera is spongy and tangy, the doro wat is rich and aromatic with berbere spice, and the vegetarian combination platter is a feast of flavors and textures that will satisfy even the most dedicated carnivores.
The restaurant is warm and welcoming, with traditional Ethiopian décor and a staff that takes genuine pride in sharing their culture through food.
If you’ve never tried Ethiopian cuisine, Abyssinia is the perfect place to start — and if you have, it’s still one of the best places in the Midwest to enjoy it.
9. Paco’s Taqueria
Located in a humble building on South East Street, Paco’s Taqueria is the kind of place that proves the best food doesn’t need a fancy address.
The tacos are simple, authentic, and loaded with flavor — al pastor carved straight from the trompo, tender carnitas, perfectly seasoned chorizo, all served on warm corn tortillas with fresh cilantro and onion.
The weekend specials, including birria and barbacoa, are worth planning your schedule around.
Paco’s is a no-frills, order-at-the-counter operation where the food speaks for itself — and it speaks volumes.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
