5 Best Pizza Places in Menifee, California to Try

Menifee, nestled in Riverside County’s growing Inland Empire, has evolved from a quiet retirement community to a dynamic family-oriented city with a surprisingly robust food scene.

The town’s pizza offerings reflect its suburban comfort, California freshness, and increasing diversity.

Here are the five best pizza places in Menifee for 2025, each bringing distinctive flavor and atmosphere to this expanding community.

1. Stadium Pizza

A true Menifee institution, Stadium Pizza has been serving the community since long before the city was incorporated.

Their hand-tossed pies feature a medium-thick, chewy crust, rich tomato sauce, and generous toppings—the “All-Star” combo and BBQ chicken varieties consistently win local acclaim.

Stadium distinguishes itself with a sports-focused atmosphere complete with memorabilia, multiple screens, and a rotating craft beer selection from nearby Temecula Valley breweries.

The family-friendly dining room, sprawling patio, and party spaces make this the go-to spot for team celebrations, family gatherings, and watching the big game while enjoying quality pies.

2. Pieology Pizzeria

For customization enthusiasts, Pieology offers a build-your-own experience with endless topping combinations on a thin, crisp crust.

Choose from dozens of sauces (classic red to olive oil or buffalo), cheeses, proteins, and vegetables before your pizza is fire-baked in minutes.

Health-conscious options including cauliflower crust, gluten-free dough, and plant-based proteins make Pieology accessible to diners with dietary restrictions.

The bright, modern space at Menifee Countryside Marketplace draws shoppers, students from nearby Mt. San Jacinto College, and families looking for personalized pizzas everyone can enjoy.

3. Mama’s Rustic Kitchen & Bar

Elevating Menifee’s pizza scene, Mama’s Rustic Kitchen crafts artisanal wood-fired pies with locally sourced ingredients and creative flavor profiles.

The slightly charred, chewy crust provides the perfect foundation for specialties like the “Fig & Pig” (prosciutto, fig jam, gorgonzola) and “California Sunrise” (fresh avocado, bacon, and an egg).

Beyond pizza, Mama’s farm-to-table approach extends to seasonal salads, craft cocktails, and housemade desserts.

The rustic-chic décor, live weekend music, and romantic lighting make this a standout date night destination in a town otherwise dominated by family dining.

4. J’s Pizza Café

This hidden gem combines New York-style pizza expertise with warm, community-focused service.

J’s thin, foldable slices feature the perfect balance of chewy interior and crisp bottom, with classic toppings and specialty combinations like the “Menifee Meat” and “White Veggie” delighting locals.

The small, cozy café atmosphere and owner-operated charm create a sense of neighborhood belonging that larger chains can’t match.

Their commitment to consistent quality, reasonable prices, and knowing regular customers by name has built a loyal following despite minimal advertising.

5. Round Table Pizza

While technically a chain, Round Table’s Menifee location has become a community fixture thanks to its consistent quality and local involvement.

Their “Last Honest Pizza” motto translates to made-from-scratch dough, real cheese, and fresh toppings piled edge-to-edge on a medium-thick crust.

The signature “King Arthur’s Supreme” and “Maui Zaui” Hawaiian pizza showcase Round Table’s generous approach to toppings.

The family-friendly setting, complete with arcade games and party rooms, makes this location particularly popular for youth sports teams and birthday celebrations.