On the Peninsula, comfort leans coastal—fried seafood baskets, Lowcountry nods, Southern sides—and plenty of hearty plates after a day by the water.
These five local favorites keep it warm and welcoming.
Second Street American Bistro
A polished neighborhood standby offering classic American comfort with a modern touch.
Meatloaf with mushroom gravy, short rib pot roast over buttery mash, and chicken pot pie with a flaky cap headline the menu.
Starter standouts include spinach-artichoke dip and deviled eggs, while desserts—think warm brownie sundaes—close the loop.
Service is friendly, the room is cozy, and it works for families and date nights alike.
Harpoon Larry’s Fish House & Oyster Bar
Casual, lively seafood comfort with real-deal freshness.
Start with a dozen Gulf oysters, then dive into fried seafood platters—shrimp, flounder, oysters—golden and crisp.
The she-crab soup is rich and sherry-kissed, crab cakes are meaty with minimal filler, and hushpuppies are the crunchy-sweet side you’ll fight over.
Cold beer, nautical vibes, and big portions make it a locals’ habit.
Fin Seafood
When you want refined comfort from the sea, Fin delivers.
Pan-seared scallops over creamy risotto, shrimp and grits with andouille depth, and crab bisque that’s silky and generously crabby.
Seasonal vegetables are prepared with care, and the dining room feels special without being stuffy. Ideal for a celebratory but still cozy meal.
Tommy’s Restaurant
A down-home diner favorite where breakfast reigns and lunches are hearty.
Omelets are stuffed and satisfying, biscuits are tender and tall, and country-fried steak with gravy sticks to your ribs in the best way.
Daily specials rotate through pot roast, turkey and dressing, and classic plate lunches.
It’s budget-friendly, quick, and full of regulars who’ve been coming for years.
Rick’s Cheese Steak Shop
Because sometimes comfort is meat, cheese, and a soft roll.
Rick’s slings hefty cheesesteaks with sizzling beef, melty provolone or whiz, and peppers and onions to taste.
Add crinkle-cut fries and a fountain drink for the full nostalgia hit.
It’s unfussy, fast, and exactly what you want on a hungry afternoon.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
