Nestled in the heart of Indiana, Carmel is a burgeoning culinary destination, boasting a diverse array of restaurants that cater to every palate.
From cozy cafes to upscale dining establishments, Carmel offers a gastronomic adventure that is sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Whether you’re a local resident or just passing through, here are 15 must-visit restaurants that promise to delight and satisfy.
1. Anthony’s Chophouse
Offering a refined dining experience, Anthony’s Chophouse is renowned for its succulent steaks and impeccable service.
Situated in the heart of Carmel’s Arts & Design District, this upscale steakhouse exudes sophistication and charm.
From the perfectly seared filet mignon to the decadent lobster mac and cheese, every dish is crafted with precision and flair.
2. Matt the Miller’s Tavern
Combining the warmth of a traditional tavern with a modern twist, Matt the Miller’s Tavern is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
With an extensive menu featuring everything from hearty burgers to fresh seafood, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
Don’t miss their famous beer-battered fish and chips or the indulgent bacon-wrapped meatloaf – both surefire crowd-pleasers that keep patrons coming back for more.
3. Divvy
Embrace the art of sharing at Divvy, where small plates take center stage.
This vibrant eatery offers a unique dining experience, allowing guests to sample an array of flavors in a communal setting.
From the delectable charcuterie boards to the inventive sushi rolls, each dish is designed to dazzle the senses.
Pair your meal with a handcrafted cocktail or choose from their extensive wine list for the perfect finishing touch.
4. MashCraft Brewing Company
For beer enthusiasts seeking a taste of local flavor, look no further than MashCraft Brewing Company.
This beloved brewery is known for its creative craft beers, brewed onsite using only the finest ingredients.
Pull up a chair in the cozy taproom and savor a flight of their latest brews, from hoppy IPAs to rich stouts.
Feeling peckish?
Be sure to sample their mouthwatering pub fare, including loaded nachos and gourmet sliders.
5. The Italian House on Park
Step into a slice of Italy at The Italian House on Park, where rustic charm meets refined cuisine.
Nestled in a historic building in downtown Carmel, this family-owned restaurant specializes in traditional Italian dishes made from scratch.
Indulge in classics like handmade pasta and wood-fired pizzas, or savor one of their signature seafood entrees.
With its warm ambiance and authentic flavors, The Italian House on Park is sure to transport you to the heart of Tuscany.
6. Woody’s Library Restaurant
Housed in a converted library, Woody’s Library Restaurant offers a dining experience steeped in history and elegance.
Guests can peruse the shelves of books while savoring an eclectic menu that blends comfort food classics with inventive twists.
From the renowned meatloaf to the mouthwatering shrimp and grits, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail.
With its cozy atmosphere and literary charm, Woody’s is a beloved destination for foodies and book lovers alike.
7. Sakura Japanese Restaurant
Embark on a culinary journey to Japan at Sakura Japanese Restaurant, where authentic flavors and impeccable presentation take center stage.
Situated in the bustling Clay Terrace shopping center, this hidden gem is a haven for sushi enthusiasts and lovers of Japanese cuisine.
Feast on expertly crafted sushi rolls, fresh sashimi, and flavorful hibachi dishes prepared right before your eyes.
With its welcoming ambiance and top-notch sushi bar, Sakura promises a dining experience that is both memorable and delicious.
8. La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant
Spice up your dining experience at La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant, where bold flavors and vibrant colors reign supreme.
This family-owned eatery is renowned for its authentic Mexican fare, featuring classics like tacos, enchiladas, and sizzling fajitas.
Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their famous margaritas, crafted with fresh-squeezed citrus and top-shelf tequila.
Whether you’re craving traditional favorites or innovative specialties, La Hacienda delivers a fiesta for the senses that will leave you coming back for more.
9. Bazbeaux Pizza
Tantalize your taste buds with a slice of heaven at Bazbeaux Pizza, a beloved pizzeria that has been serving up gourmet pies since 1986.
With its eclectic menu and commitment to quality ingredients, Bazbeaux has earned a reputation as one of Carmel’s top spots for pizza aficionados.
Choose from an array of creative toppings and specialty pies, or craft your own culinary masterpiece.
Whether you prefer classic combinations or bold flavor pairings, Bazbeaux delivers a pizza experience that is sure to satisfy.
10. The Garden Table
Embrace a farm-to-table dining experience at The Garden Table, where fresh, seasonal ingredients take center stage.
This charming café is dedicated to serving wholesome, nourishing dishes that celebrate the bounty of the earth.
From nutrient-rich salads to hearty grain bowls, each dish is thoughtfully crafted to promote health and vitality.
Pair your meal with a cold-pressed juice or artisanal coffee for the perfect pick-me-up.
With its emphasis on sustainability and wellness, The Garden Table offers a dining experience that nourishes both body and soul.
11. Pint Room
Raise a glass to good times at Pint Room, a lively gastropub that boasts an impressive selection of craft beers and gourmet burgers.
With over 100 beers on tap and a menu featuring creative twists on pub classics, there’s no shortage of options to tantalize your taste buds.
From juicy burgers piled high with inventive toppings to crispy fish tacos bursting with flavor, every dish is designed to pair perfectly with your favorite brew.
Whether you’re a beer connoisseur or simply seeking a laid-back atmosphere to unwind with friends, Pint Room has something for everyone to enjoy.
12. The Cake Bake Shop
Indulge your sweet tooth at The Cake Bake Shop, a whimsical bakery that specializes in decadent desserts and elaborate cakes.
Step into a fairy-tale world of pastel hues and vintage charm as you peruse a dazzling array of confections, from towering layer cakes to delicate macarons.
Treat yourself to a slice of their famous triple-chocolate mousse cake or savor a fluffy slice of coconut cream pie.
With its enchanting ambiance and mouthwatering treats, The Cake Bake Shop is a dessert lover’s paradise that promises to satisfy even the most discerning palate.
13. Bru Burger Bar
Elevate your burger game at Bru Burger Bar, where handcrafted burgers and artisanal brews take center stage.
Situated in the heart of Carmel’s bustling Arts & Design District, this contemporary gastropub offers a menu packed with creative twists on classic comfort food favorites.
Sink your teeth into the juicy Bru Burger piled high with gourmet toppings, or opt for the flavorful veggie burger made with a blend of fresh vegetables and spices.
Pair your meal with a cold draft beer or inventive cocktail for the ultimate dining experience.
With its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering fare, Bru Burger Bar is a destination worth savoring.
14. Four Day Ray Brewing
Raise a glass to local flavor at Four Day Ray Brewing, a craft brewery and gastropub located in the heart of Carmel’s bustling downtown.
Named in honor of Indiana’s prohibition history, Four Day Ray pays homage to the spirit of craftsmanship and innovation.
Sip on a flight of their latest brews, from crisp lagers to robust stouts, while savoring a menu of elevated pub fare.
Indulge in hearty favorites like the beer-braised short rib poutine or the signature Four Day Ray burger, crafted with locally sourced ingredients.
With its laid-back atmosphere and commitment to quality, Four Day Ray Brewing offers a taste of Indiana hospitality that keeps patrons coming back for more.
15. Soho Cafe & Gallery
Experience the intersection of art and cuisine at Soho Cafe & Gallery, a cozy cafe nestled in Carmel’s vibrant Arts & Design District.
This eclectic eatery doubles as an art gallery, showcasing the works of local artists while serving up a menu of globally inspired dishes.
From savory crepes to gourmet sandwiches, each dish is crafted with care and creativity.
Pair your meal with a glass of wine or specialty cocktail, and take in the vibrant atmosphere as you peruse the gallery’s ever-changing exhibits.
With its fusion of flavors and artistic flair, Soho Cafe & Gallery offers a dining experience that is as enriching as it is delicious.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
