Peoria has a legit bar‑and‑grill culture, and burgers are one of the things it does best. These five places come up constantly when locals debate the best burger in town.
1. Rhythm Kitchen Music Café
Known for live music and eclectic food, Rhythm Kitchen also happens to serve one of Peoria’s favorite burgers.
The burger tends to be a thick, well‑seasoned patty with creative toppings—think cheddar, bacon, grilled onions, maybe some Cajun or Creole influence in the spices or sauces. It’s the kind of burger that feels handcrafted, not “stamped out,” and eating it in a live‑music setting makes it even better.
2. Kelleher’s Irish Pub & Eatery
Right along the riverfront, Kelleher’s is a classic Irish pub with a strong burger game.
You’ll find several options: a straightforward cheeseburger, bacon‑and‑cheddar builds, mushroom‑Swiss versions, and occasional specials. Patties are generous and juicy, and the burgers come on toasted buns with all the usual fixings. Irish pub fries and a pint of Guinness or a local beer make this a go‑to for a lot of Peoria residents.
3. The Publik House (Peoria Heights)
Just up the road in Peoria Heights, The Publik House is often mentioned when burger lovers compare notes.
Gastropub‑style burgers with better‑than‑average toppings: high‑quality cheese, thick‑cut bacon, caramelized onions, fried eggs, and house sauces. The bun is soft and slightly sweet, and the patties are cooked to order, so you actually get a real medium or medium‑rare if you want it. The cozy bar setting makes it a great “burger and a beer” stop.
4. Blue Duck Barbecue Tavern
Known primarily for smoked meats, Blue Duck also earns praise for its burger—especially from people who like serious meat flavor.
The burger often incorporates smoked or charred elements: smoked cheddar, bacon, or even brisket‑topped burgers as specials. Expect a juicy patty, big flavor, and rich toppings that make this a fork‑and‑knife situation for some people. River views and strong sides (mac and cheese, cornbread, fries) help it stand out.
5. Schooners
A classic neighborhood tavern with a “hidden gem” burger reputation.
Burgers here are old‑school: hand‑formed patties, seared on a flat‑top, with cheese melted to the edges. You can add bacon, onions, jalapeños, and more, but the real magic is in the beef and the way it’s cooked. Many regulars will tell you this is the place to go if you want that timeless Midwestern tavern burger experience.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
